Differentiate or Die: Compete to Win in a Commodity B2B Tech Market

Key takeaways

  • Signs you’re in a commodity market: lookalike competitors, price wars, feature-list battles and “good enough” buying.
  • The way out has three parts: elevate to an executive buyer, wake up the market with a provocative conversation, and reframe the problem around an executive-level initiative.
  • Vendavo tied pricing to the commercial excellence initiative; Optimizely reframed A/B testing as digital experience optimization.

6:24

What is the most effective positioning strategy for winning in a commodity market? How do you compete when pricing wars are common, the buying criteria is based on feature checklists, and every vendor sounds the same?

From our experience positioning more than 400 B2B tech companies, Firebrick has unlocked the secrets to successful positioning in a commodity market. Bob Wright and Bob Macdonald share their insights and a proven strategy for separating from the pack, including how to:

  • Win the hearts of executive buyers
  • Shape new buying criteria in your favor
  • Redefine the category to set you up for new growth

Also available in this series,The World’s Best B2B Tech Presentations, Three Keys for Successful Positioning, Not for the faint of heart, Symptoms you have a positioning problem, Positioning vs. Branding: Clearing up the confusion, B2B Positioning, CEO or CMO agenda?, Is your positioning winning or losing?, Stop the geek speak, Setting the foundation for successful positioning, B2B Positioning with and agency or in-house, When positioning expires, and The best product rarely wins.

Read the transcript

Bob McDonald: Hi, this is Bob McDonald, and welcome to Differentiate or Die, the Firebrick Consulting podcast series that focuses on the keys to great positioning. On this edition, Firebrick founder Bob Wright and I are going to be discussing the strategy of competing in a commodity market. Bob, you’ve helped facilitate successful positioning outcomes for close to 400 companies now, and I’m sure a lot of them felt their technology was being viewed as a commodity.

Bob Wright: We’ve all seen it, right? The market’s been created, the market took off, the market’s been established — and then you’re facing a situation where everybody looks the same. There’s no clear differentiation between you and the hundreds of other competitors in the marketplace. A pricing war has broken out, there’s lots of discounting, everyone competes on who has the longest feature list, and “good enough” is okay.

Bob McDonald: So those are the signs that you’re in a commodity situation.

Bob Wright: You are competing in a commodity market.

Bob McDonald: Is a commodity market ever hopeless, or is there always a path to better positioning?

Bob Wright: Of course there’s a path. There’s a very specific positioning strategy for B2B tech companies competing in a commodity market.

Bob McDonald: What’s that strategy?

Bob Wright: First, you have to elevate and align to an executive buyer. Second, you have to wake up the market with a provocative conversation. And third, you have to reframe the issue or problem by connecting it to a larger executive-level initiative.

Elevating to an executive buyer

Bob McDonald: What’s happening when you get into a commodity situation? Are you not talking to executives at that point?

Bob Wright: I’ll give you a perfect example. We had a client by the name of Vendavo, competing in the pricing market. They were stuck in the bowels of the pricing function, with long sales cycles, not a lot of differentiation, and no urgency. In response, the company bought a CPQ company because that market was starting to take off — but again, they were competing with hundreds of other CPQ companies. Every time they tried to make pricing a strategic initiative for an executive buyer, the CEO said, “Hey, that’s not my issue. Go talk to my pricing function.” So we decided to shake up the market with a provocative viewpoint and shift to an executive-level conversation. We drafted off a newly funded initiative being pushed by firms like Bain and McKinsey called commercial excellence. And we built a case that, because of Vendavo’s unique capabilities in margin management, they could really fill the space between CRM and ERP.

Bob McDonald: You couldn’t elevate to an executive buyer with the old messaging, because the old messaging was developed for people further down in the organization. So they go hand in hand — you need the provocative conversation.

Reframing the issue

Bob McDonald: Let’s talk about the third pillar, reframing the issue. What does that mean?

Bob Wright: The reframe is absolutely critical for strong positioning, particularly in commodity markets. Take Optimizely and A/B testing. They were stuck in the bowels of the marketing organization doing A/B testing. They did a successful reframe: A/B testing became digital experience optimization. As every function has become digital, that requires optimizing the digital experience. So they began a strategic conversation saying experimentation, instrumentation and digital experience optimization are the new business model. They turned A/B testing into DXO — a new business model with application across the whole organization, not just the traditional places where A/B testing took place. That’s helping them drive significant revenue growth, because they’ve moved from the bowels of the marketing organization up to a strategic conversation about business models: how to innovate, experiment and keep up with companies like Netflix and Amazon. That has ramifications not only in marketing, but in product and across the entire organization.

Bob McDonald: So to wrap up: being in a commodity situation is not hopeless, and it’s not a roadblock to your future.

Bob Wright: There’s always a way out, if you adopt the right positioning strategy.

Bob McDonald: Thank you for joining us for this edition of Differentiate or Die. We invite you to listen to all of our podcasts on the Firebrick website at firebk.com. For Bob Wright, this is Bob McDonald saying goodbye.